|
Introduction
The term
‘dysplasia’ means abnormal growth; thus hip dysplasia is the
developmental condition that results in abnormal looseness or laxity of
the hip joints. It is currently accepted to be a multifactorial
disease with heredity, nutrition, trauma, and exercise, etc. all
influencing the outcome of the condition. The inherited component
is caused by the interaction of many genes – hence it is a polygenetic
condition. However, the expression of the genes may be modified by
the environmental factors listed above. These environmental
factors do not cause hip dysplasia but they may influence how unstable
the hip joint becomes and how much osteoarthritis ultimately develops as
a result of that instability.
Unlike other breeds,
the Border Collie does not usually show physical signs of HD.
Border Collies can appear normal and have good movement, but on
examination by X-Ray clearly show that they are affected by HD to
varying degrees. Border Collie breeders have been known to say
that their lines are clear and that they have no problem with HD, but
unless they have all their breeding stock X-Rayed and scored this
statement may be unfounded. If breeders have been scoring their
breeding stock and offspring for many generations and the scores are
low, for example, less than five, then they may consider that they have
a reduced chance of producing a severely affected animal.
What Happens
The hip joints of
all puppies are reported to be normal at birth, but some time after two
weeks of age the femoral head (or ball) of a dysplastic puppy fails to
sit firmly within its acetabulum (or socket) and the joint becomes
unstable.
It tends to occur
more frequently in large, well fed, fast growing, active breeds of dogs,
such as German Shepherds, Labradors, Saint Bernards, Great Danes and
Newfoundlands. It has a genetic basis and affects both sexes with
equal frequency. Affected dogs are born with normal hip joints
that subsequently undergo progressive structural changes. There
are marked variations in the severity of time of onset of such changes,
the age at which clinical signs occur, the rate of disease progression
and the degree of pain and impaired mobility. Some dogs will be
lame in a few months while others may not have pain for years.
Signs and
Symptoms
Difficulty in rising form a sitting
position or reluctant to walk up stairs, as well as morning stiffness
after sleeping.
A swaying or waddle gait in the hind legs
when walking or actual lameness.
Pain if the pelvis area is pressed.
Reluctance to jump, with stiffness after
exercise
Inability to take full weight on the back
legs alone
Wasting or poor development of hind legs
musculature in advanced cases
A clicking sound can sometimes be heard as
the femoral heads subluxate.
Not all of these
signs are necessarily seen at the same time.
Diagnosis
The diagnosis of hip
dysplasia is made by physical examination and radiographic evidence.
Within Australia a dog has to be over the age of 12 months for the X-Ray
to be officially scored. The X-Ray is taken with the dog placed on
its back with its pelvis symmetrical and both hind legs extended and
parallel. It is generally necessary to anaesthetise the dog
to position it correctly. Several tests are done on both hips to
determine the degree of laxity and dislocation of the joints. When
the X-Ray is scored, the following parameters are assessed:
- The degree
of subluxation of the femoral heads (ball)
- The
condition of the dorsal, cranial and caudal acetabular (socket) rims
- The shape
of the femoral heads and necks
- New bone
formation
- Other
evidence of osteoarthritis
The hips of a racing
Greyhound are generally regarded as normal and are used for comparison.
The X-Ray is sent off to one of three assessment schemes, where
veterinary radiologists provide an opinion on the HD status. Each
hip is given a score from 0 to 53 and then based on this the degree is
graded 1 – 6, with 6 being the most severe. It should be noted at
this stage that there is no relationship between the degree of change
seen on the X-Ray and the severity of pain seen clinically.
Treatment
Treatment depends on
results of the HD assessment and falls into 4 categories:
-
Conservative
approach (absolute rest for several weeks or months). This is
mainly if the changes are slight and pain is minimal.
-
Conservative
approach plus therapy with pain killing drugs (analgesics).
-
Surgical removal
of the pectineus muscle near the groin to give the hip greater
freedom or movement.
-
Surgical removal
of the “ball” itself if degeneration is severe.
-
Surgical
correction of particular problems including changing the angle of
the ball and socket joints.
In addition, several
successful total hip replacement operations have now been performed in
Australia, although the cost of such operations is very high in
comparison with other methods.
The long term
outlook depends on the dog’s clinical condition and the owner’s
attitude. It should be remembered that radiographic (X-Ray)
diagnosis of HD alone should not be a reason to euthanase (put to sleep)
the dog. Euthanasia should be considered if the dog is suffering
with the condition and treatment is not helping. However, HD on an
X-Ray is an indication to avoid breeding with the dog if HD is
ever to be successfully controlled in dogs generally.
What
You Can Do
Currently
many dog clubs are requiring HD assessments be performed before allowing
pedigree dogs to be used for breeding. It is advisable to check
the HD status of the parents of any pup you are purchasing.
All breeders, as a
minimum should X-Ray all breeding stock and submit all X-Rays for
scoring. The importance of submitting all X-Rays for scoring,
particularly if they appear poor, is to obtain a true breed average.
What has happened in the past is that X-Rays that definitely show a
moderate to severe problem were not necessarily submitted for scoring.
Therefore the higher scores are not included in the data. We have
a breed average that is not a true reflection of the degree to which
Border Collies are affected by HD and an artificially low breed average
score.
For example, you dog
has received a total score of 13 but because only moderately affected
dog’s X-Rays have been submitted for scoring, the breed average is 9.
Therefore you dog may not be recommended for breeding because it exceeds
the breed average. However, if all X-Rays were submitted the breed
average may be 15 and therefore you dog would be suitable for breeding.
The more Border Collies are X-Rayed and hip scored, the more information
we will have concerning this disease and the better the ability of
breeders to improve the breed. Other breeds are undertaking such
control measures through their club regulations.
Prevention
It
is questionable whether HD can ever be fully eliminated from a breed
because often dogs are used for breeding before clinical signs appear in
them. Indeed, some dogs with HD are never X-Rayed or assessed
because owners do not seek a HD assessment if clinical signs do not
appear in their dogs. Hence, further control can only be achieved
on a general basis if owners and breeders become more aware of the facts
concerning HD in their dogs
Resources Used
Veterinary Notes For
Dog Breeders – Annette M Carricato
Veterinary Notes For Dog Owners – Edited by Trevor Turner
What’s the Diagnosis? – Race Foster & Mary Smith
Veterinary Practice Nurse – April 1993, John Foster
Queensland Dog World, October 1992 & September 1994
Click here for:
More Hip Dysplasia Information |